- Boards
- PlayStation 4
- These were the dominant goty winners from 2003 to 2016
|
Incase you were wondering what game took the most awards for each given year since 2003, well here they are.
2003 STAR WARS KOTR 2004 HALF LIFE 2 2005 RESIDENT EVIL 4 2006 ELDER SCROLLS OBLIVION 2007 BIOSHOCK 2008 FALLOUT 3 2009 UNCHARTED 2 2010 RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2011 ELDER SCROLLS SKYRIM 2012 WALKING DEAD 2013 THE LAST OF US 2014 DRAGON AGE INQUISITION 2015 WITCHER 3 2016 UNCHARTED 4 BIGGEST WINNER : Naughty dog studios https://gotypicks.blogspot.com/?m=1 So there we have it. What do you have to say? Do you think it was well deserved? What 2017 game should join this list as the biggest winner?
You want facts? I bring them
|
|
Ultimaspirit posted...
Am I missing something? Three Bethesda games, three ND games. When calculating all awards Tlou is actually the 2nd most awarded game ever
You want facts? I bring them
(edited 18 hours ago)quote
|
|
GamingGod posted...
When calculating all awards Oh okay, I get it now. |
|
Huh... So I haven't cared for a "dominant" GOTY since 2008 except for Skyrim... Not entirely surprised...
NNID:MrOddities|PSN:OddGamer2013
Playing:Persona 5|Smite|The Binding of Isaac Afterbirth+|Warframe|Ever Oasis|Splatoon 2|Diablo 3|RPG Maker FES|Fortnite |
|
Huh, I thought 2016 had OW with the most awards
Edit: and actually there's a gap of 60 or so awardsa in UC4's favor. Whaddayaknow.
(edited 17 hours ago)quote
|
|
Ultimaspirit posted...
GamingGod posted...When calculating all awards I already knew it
To the edge of the universe and back, endure and survive
|
|
I'm glad so many other people enjoy Naughty Dog's games.
I'd probably like them too if they had gameplay deeper than a puddle.
"I hate this site but I also can't look away from it. It's like a trainwreck that just keeps perpetually happening every day."
|
|
mgs4 and gta4 >>>>> fallout 3, lol.
anytime Gordon Ramsey cooks meat, he always serves it raw. are you guys serious?
|
|
mArKEd
.
I always win online. DEWD RAIDER: aka UNCHARTED: A Tomb Raider wannabe corridor simulator for casuals who can't play platform or explore on their own.
|
|
No Nintendo games? Seems biased.
I like games and anime. My favorite games include the following: Mother 1-3, Final Fantasy VI, Chrono Cross, Zelda LA-ALttP-OoT-MM-ALBW, and Super Smash Bros.
|
|
lemme guess most of those are western media awards? The list looks very western biased.
Xenoblade , FF12, and MGS3 are absent. I mean it's not a horrible list, but alot of those games were just hyped up western games,.
My top 10 PS4 games = FFX HD, The Last of Us Remastered, Bloodborne, Uncharted 4, Horizon Zero Dawn, Persona 5, Yakuza 0, FF12 HD, Until Dawn, Journey.
|
|
CRIMSON-XIII posted...
mgs4 and gta4 >>>>> fallout 3, lol. fallout 3 aged like crap lol. MGS4 and GTA4 are still fun to play. Fallout 3s aiming is atrocious.
My top 10 PS4 games = FFX HD, The Last of Us Remastered, Bloodborne, Uncharted 4, Horizon Zero Dawn, Persona 5, Yakuza 0, FF12 HD, Until Dawn, Journey.
|
|
You know... I could have sworn Super Mario Galaxy won GOTY in its year of release.
We're outnumbered ten to one here.
Still, I love the odds. |
|
SaturnSnowman posted...
No Nintendo games? Seems biased. Galaxy won awards, but I guess Bioshock took the majority that year. Not sure about Galaxy 2 vs Uncharted 2, but I guess Galaxy 2 actually won some, too. Oh well, at least 2017 will be either BotW or Odyssey. |
|
random_man9119 posted...
Huh... So I haven't cared for a "dominant" GOTY since 2008 except for Skyrim... Not entirely surprised... you seriously skipped red dead redemption? that might have been one of the greatest games ever, kinda. |
|
iiiiiiiiiiiii posted...
you seriously skipped red dead redemption? that might have been one of the greatest games ever, kinda. I legit didn't care for that game. |
|
what about bloodborne?
Gamertag XL: CRAZYjump, PSN: CRAZIERjump
Winner: Dark Souls.....2, Honorable Mentions: Fallout 3, Gears of War, Left 4 Dead, Dead Space, Bioshock |
|
Pretty bad list.
Also 2014 must've been the worst year ever if a complete piece of shit like DA:I can get GOTY. |
|
iiiiiiiiiiiii posted...
random_man9119 posted...Huh... So I haven't cared for a "dominant" GOTY since 2008 except for Skyrim... Not entirely surprised... overrated game
If you like RPGs, play The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky
|
|
Why are we starting with an arbitrary year like 2003?
[J.S.] The Lost King ---> http://justsnilloc.proboards.com/
~~~~ 0====[[::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::x::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::}}====0 ~~~~ |
|
GamingGod posted...
Ultimaspirit posted...Am I missing something? Three Bethesda games, three ND games. And Skyrim is the third. Oblivion was the most award winning game ever in 2006 as well |
|
GamingGod posted...
Incase you were wondering what game took the most awards for each given year since 2003, well here they are. fixed that for you OP |
|
Super Mario Galaxy was 2007's GOTY. If I remember correctly, it had far more awards than BioShock.
I dislike GTAIV (most of them), but that seemed to be better received than Fallout 3.
Political correctness is indeed fascism.
|
|
lnfinity_Divide posted...
Pretty bad list. It was a pretty bad year. We were in a drought when it came to high quality rpg's especially on the PS4/XBONE.
Today is the day: Bomberman, Paper Mario, K.Rool, Wonder Red, and Goku for Smash.
|
|
JosephDigital posted...
Super Mario Galaxy was 2007's GOTY. If I remember correctly, it had far more awards than BioShock. On the big sites, but BioShock son in many smaler sites Also Grand theft auto has never has the most awards |
|
SamuraiSkillz posted...
GamingGod posted...Incase you were wondering what game took the most awards for each given year since 2003, well here they are. It's sad because ND wasn't always so SJW, Neil Cuckmann really ruined them. |
|
PS4TW posted...
lemme guess most of those are western media awards? The list looks very western biased. It was taken from all relevant sites. There's no bias there
You want facts? I bring them
|
|
Megathorn22 posted...
You know... I could have sworn Super Mario Galaxy won GOTY in its year of release. It did win. Just not the majority
You want facts? I bring them
|
|
hak145 posted...
what about bloodborne? Lol u can't be serious In a year when Witcher 3 released?
You want facts? I bring them
|
|
JosephDigital posted...
Super Mario Galaxy was 2007's GOTY. If I remember correctly, it had far more awards than BioShock. I also thought it was Mario Galaxy till I saw the definitive list counting all awards, to my surprise Bioshock topped
You want facts? I bring them
(edited 15 hours ago)quote
|
|
2015 is like the 1994 Oscars.
Bloodborne is Pulp Fiction (the more acclaimed but more divisive masterpiece which will stand the test of time) while The Witcher 3 is Forrest Gump (the more accessible game but without the intricacies of the former).
"Foolish guac bowl merchant!" - Big Man Tyrone
|
|
Seeing RDR on the same list as DA:I is mind boggling to say the least.
Playing: BF1, Bloodborne, Don't Starve Together
|
|
Iv never seen a gamefaqs user so infatuated with a game studio as TC
Fan of Sega, Playstation and Xbox
|
|
VettiSforza posted...
2015 is like the 1994 Oscars. It'll only stand the test of time if everyone looking back disregards how technically terrible the game is. From is easily one of the least competent large developers from a technical standpoint |
|
Rand_Aybara posted...
VettiSforza posted...2015 is like the 1994 Oscars. Most people judge games on plot and gameplay. Unless the game is a buggy, broken mess, I don't see many people using a game's technical aspect as the main criteria for judging its worth.
"Foolish guac bowl merchant!" - Big Man Tyrone
|
|
Rand_Aybara posted...
VettiSforza posted...2015 is like the 1994 Oscars. Care to elaborate on how BB is technically terrible? Genuinely curious.
Playing: BF1, Bloodborne, Don't Starve Together
|
|
GamingGod posted...
Incase you were wondering what game took the most awards for each given year since 2003, well here they are. Ones I played/cared about/liked in bold. If anyone cares.
Sac City Gamer - saccitygamer.com
(edited 14 hours ago)quote
|
|
GamingGod posted...
hak145 posted...what about bloodborne? Bloodborne was better.
Kept you waiting, huh?
|
|
Charging_Zebra posted...
The Walking Dead was GOTY? 2012 must have been a terrible year. TWD was actually pretty groundbreaking when it came out. It proved that a game could have minimal gameplay but a great story and still be widely praised in today's age of bloated, flashy AAA titles.
"Foolish guac bowl merchant!" - Big Man Tyrone
|
|
binaryvegeta posted...
GamingGod posted...hak145 posted...what about bloodborne? Nah. |
|
We just talking Sony systems, because if not then you are horribly mistaken on a lot of those years. ( and even then you are wrong on some years, like 2016 for example)
*edit nvm, I see you got it from a blog (which seems to maybe have skewed info since a few months ago Overwatch had the most GOTY awards)
Currently Playing :Fortnite (PC) & Final Fantasy XII The Zodiac Age
(edited 14 hours ago)quote
|
|
Interesting list but assume it is only taken from relevant English language sites. Ie, does it include awards handed out by Japanese, Chinese, Spanish, French etc websites
2600, NES, GB, SNES, SMD, NGX, GBC, DGOO, LYNX, PS1, SAT, N64, 3DO, GBA, PS2, GCN, XBOX, DC, PSP, DS, PS3, X360, WII, VITA, 3DS, OUYA, XONE, PS4
|
|
Comyx posted...
binaryvegeta posted...GamingGod posted...hak145 posted...what about bloodborne? Yah.
Kept you waiting, huh?
|
|
Thanks for listing some of the most overrated games of all time.
You simply cannot see the forest for the trees, You're not able to comprehend the true meaning of peace or what I'm trying to accomplish.
|
|
Desner posted...
Rand_Aybara posted...VettiSforza posted...2015 is like the 1994 Oscars. Horrible frame pacing, almost non-existent texture filtering, extensive use of filters and blur to cover up just how poor their technical ability is. As far as pure fidelity goes Bloodborne is below average for this generation and it still manages to run extremely poorly. Not to mention there are places where you can literally see through the level geometry because of how poorly they built the game world. It's still a fun game with fantastic art direction, it's just severely let down by From's technical incompetence. |
|
GamingGod posted...
Ultimaspirit posted...Am I missing something? Three Bethesda games, three ND games. fanboys are actually at the point where they're calculating each individual award to actually prove a point sad. cant wait for the fanboys war at the end of the year : yea zelda got X amount of goty award. best game ever! no no fu tlou got 3 more awards its clearly the best game blablabla
(edited 14 hours ago)quote
|
- Boards
- PlayStation 4
- These were the dominant goty winners from 2003 to 2016
- Boards
- PlayStation 4
- These were the dominant goty winners from 2003 to 2016
Rand_Aybara posted...Desner posted...
Rand_Aybara posted...
VettiSforza posted...
2015 is like the 1994 Oscars.
Bloodborne is Pulp Fiction (the more acclaimed but more divisive masterpiece which will stand the test of time) while The Witcher 3 is Forrest Gump (the more accessible game but without the intricacies of the former).
It'll only stand the test of time if everyone looking back disregards how technically terrible the game is. From is easily one of the least competent large developers from a technical standpoint
Care to elaborate on how BB is technically terrible? Genuinely curious.
Horrible frame pacing, almost non-existent texture filtering, extensive use of filters and blur to cover up just how poor their technical ability is. As far as pure fidelity goes Bloodborne is below average for this generation and it still manages to run extremely poorly. Not to mention there are places where you can literally see through the level geometry because of how poorly they built the game world.
It's still a fun game with fantastic art direction, it's just severely let down by From's technical incompetence.
No one's going to care about any of that, Shadow of the colossus is still considered a masterpiece and that game was an actual technical nightmare with severe fps drops and hanky controls, etc.
It's hard to see the truth of this being on gamefaqs where people bitch about every little thing cause someone pointed it out in some article but fact is the average gamer doesn't even notice things like frame pacing.SaturnSnowman posted...No Nintendo games? Seems biased.
2002 was the last time they had a real contender for GOTY. They have 2017 locked though.the end of one nightmare, prelude to the another...
Shenmue IIIBillo posted...Rand_Aybara posted...
Desner posted...
Rand_Aybara posted...
VettiSforza posted...
2015 is like the 1994 Oscars.
Bloodborne is Pulp Fiction (the more acclaimed but more divisive masterpiece which will stand the test of time) while The Witcher 3 is Forrest Gump (the more accessible game but without the intricacies of the former).
It'll only stand the test of time if everyone looking back disregards how technically terrible the game is. From is easily one of the least competent large developers from a technical standpoint
Care to elaborate on how BB is technically terrible? Genuinely curious.
Horrible frame pacing, almost non-existent texture filtering, extensive use of filters and blur to cover up just how poor their technical ability is. As far as pure fidelity goes Bloodborne is below average for this generation and it still manages to run extremely poorly. Not to mention there are places where you can literally see through the level geometry because of how poorly they built the game world.
It's still a fun game with fantastic art direction, it's just severely let down by From's technical incompetence.
No one's going to care about any of that, Shadow of the colossus is still considered a masterpiece and that game was an actual technical nightmare with severe fps drops and hanky controls, etc.
It's hard to see the truth of this being on gamefaqs where people bitch about every little thing cause someone pointed it out in some article but fact is the average gamer doesn't even notice things like frame pacing.
That isn't true at all. I know plenty of people that are "average gamers" and most of them care about game performance to some extent.Mr_Big_Boss posted...SaturnSnowman posted...
No Nintendo games? Seems biased.
2002 was the last time they had a real contender for GOTY. They have 2017 locked though.
Pretty sure Twilight Princess and Mario Galaxy were both incredibly well-liked by just about every review website the years they came out. To say they aren't even contenders is a lie.I like games and anime. My favorite games include the following: Mother 1-3, Final Fantasy VI, Chrono Cross, Zelda LA-ALttP-OoT-MM-ALBW, and Super Smash Bros.SaturnSnowman posted...Mr_Big_Boss posted...
SaturnSnowman posted...
No Nintendo games? Seems biased.
2002 was the last time they had a real contender for GOTY. They have 2017 locked though.
Pretty sure Twilight Princess and Mario Galaxy were both incredibly well-liked by just about every review website the years they came out. To say they aren't even contenders is a lie.
He'll, Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 and generally considered some of the best games (If not the best) games of Gen 7Currently Playing :Fortnite (PC) & Final Fantasy XII The Zodiac AgeRand_Aybara posted...Billo posted...
Rand_Aybara posted...
Desner posted...
Rand_Aybara posted...
VettiSforza posted...
2015 is like the 1994 Oscars.
Bloodborne is Pulp Fiction (the more acclaimed but more divisive masterpiece which will stand the test of time) while The Witcher 3 is Forrest Gump (the more accessible game but without the intricacies of the former).
It'll only stand the test of time if everyone looking back disregards how technically terrible the game is. From is easily one of the least competent large developers from a technical standpoint
Care to elaborate on how BB is technically terrible? Genuinely curious.
Horrible frame pacing, almost non-existent texture filtering, extensive use of filters and blur to cover up just how poor their technical ability is. As far as pure fidelity goes Bloodborne is below average for this generation and it still manages to run extremely poorly. Not to mention there are places where you can literally see through the level geometry because of how poorly they built the game world.
It's still a fun game with fantastic art direction, it's just severely let down by From's technical incompetence.
No one's going to care about any of that, Shadow of the colossus is still considered a masterpiece and that game was an actual technical nightmare with severe fps drops and hanky controls, etc.
It's hard to see the truth of this being on gamefaqs where people bitch about every little thing cause someone pointed it out in some article but fact is the average gamer doesn't even notice things like frame pacing.
That isn't true at all. I know plenty of people that are "average gamers" and most of them care about game performance to some extent.
"To some extent" yes, but Bloodborne's issues are minor and not noticeable. Only thing I ever saw complaints about were the load times before they were patched.
Seriously if Bethesda games can be considered good with all their problems, then Bloodborne certainly isn't going to be looked upon as a game with technical issues in hindsight, it's a technical marvel compared to Bethesda games, and as I pointed out earlier Shadow of the Colossus.
Bloodborne' technical problems are extremely minor and certainly don't hamper the experience in the slightest.(edited 13 hours ago)quoteMaverick_Reznor posted...SaturnSnowman posted...
Mr_Big_Boss posted...
SaturnSnowman posted...
No Nintendo games? Seems biased.
2002 was the last time they had a real contender for GOTY. They have 2017 locked though.
Pretty sure Twilight Princess and Mario Galaxy were both incredibly well-liked by just about every review website the years they came out. To say they aren't even contenders is a lie.
He'll, Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 and generally considered some of the best games (If not the best) games of Gen 7
Super Mario Galaxy is the highest rated exclusive of gen 7 and tied for second-highest rated game, IIRC.(edited 13 hours ago)quoteBillo posted...Rand_Aybara posted...
Billo posted...
Rand_Aybara posted...
Desner posted...
Rand_Aybara posted...
VettiSforza posted...
2015 is like the 1994 Oscars.
Bloodborne is Pulp Fiction (the more acclaimed but more divisive masterpiece which will stand the test of time) while The Witcher 3 is Forrest Gump (the more accessible game but without the intricacies of the former).
It'll only stand the test of time if everyone looking back disregards how technically terrible the game is. From is easily one of the least competent large developers from a technical standpoint
Care to elaborate on how BB is technically terrible? Genuinely curious.
Horrible frame pacing, almost non-existent texture filtering, extensive use of filters and blur to cover up just how poor their technical ability is. As far as pure fidelity goes Bloodborne is below average for this generation and it still manages to run extremely poorly. Not to mention there are places where you can literally see through the level geometry because of how poorly they built the game world.
It's still a fun game with fantastic art direction, it's just severely let down by From's technical incompetence.
No one's going to care about any of that, Shadow of the colossus is still considered a masterpiece and that game was an actual technical nightmare with severe fps drops and hanky controls, etc.
It's hard to see the truth of this being on gamefaqs where people bitch about every little thing cause someone pointed it out in some article but fact is the average gamer doesn't even notice things like frame pacing.
That isn't true at all. I know plenty of people that are "average gamers" and most of them care about game performance to some extent.
"To some extent" yes, but Bloodborne's issues are minor and not noticeable. Only thing I ever saw complaints about were the load times before they were patched.
Seriously if Bethesda games can be considered good with all their problems, then Bloodborne certainly isn't going to be looked upon as a game with technical issues in hindsight, it's a technical marvel compared to Bethesda games, and as I pointed out earlier Shadow of the Colossus.
Bloodborne' technical problems are extremely minor and certainly don't hamper the experience in the slightest.
Bloodborne runs like crap compared to Bethesda's games while managing to look significantly worse and is much less complex. Bethesda's games really only run poorly on the PS3, they're fine on every other system. They don't have frame pacing issues, they don't have to rely on post processing to hide anything because they can actually design a game that looks good and runs decently. The only time their games have truly run poorly was because of the PS3's memory architecture.
The technical issues in Bloodborne do hamper the experience. The frame pacing makes it hard to time attacks or dodges correctly at times, and the amount of stuttering can be pretty distracting at times, enough to actually diminish the experience for some people.(edited 13 hours ago)quoteBloodborne runs like crap compared to Bethesda's games
Okay I'm done arguing with you now, you're clearly out of your mind.Super Mario Galaxy received Game of the Year 2007 awards from various big and influential game media such as IGN, gamespot, kotaku, gametrailers, edge, famitsu, gamerankings,
even gamefaqs readers chosen it as 2007's goty.
TC just fanboyed out the list to exclude it.(edited 13 hours ago)quoteBillo posted...Bloodborne runs like crap compared to Bethesda's games
Okay I'm done arguing with you now, you're clearly out of your mind.
Not even close. They run extremely well on PC, Skyrim is easily one of the most optimized games in recent history especially when taking SLI support into account, and they're stable on current gen systems. They don't stutter and skip like Bloodborne does. They may have some frame rate drops on consoles, not any worse than Bloodborne and they don't have frame pacing issues, but they actually have a halfway decent motion blur solution that does a good job of hiding all but the most severe drops. Bloodborne does notI agree with the first three, the rest range between highly questionable and wrongI don't just sell stuff, I am actually involved in these.
Now, I'm motivated!SaturnSnowman posted...No Nintendo games? Seems biased.
If nintendos zelda were multiplat, im sure wind waker would be a dominant goty.
But sadly Nintendo are too greedy to share. Well its not like they can help it. They only have a few titles to move their consoles to stay afloat in this brutal competitive gaming market.(edited 12 hours ago)quoteSaturnSnowman posted...Mr_Big_Boss posted...
SaturnSnowman posted...
No Nintendo games? Seems biased.
2002 was the last time they had a real contender for GOTY. They have 2017 locked though.
Pretty sure Twilight Princess and Mario Galaxy were both incredibly well-liked by just about every review website the years they came out. To say they aren't even contenders is a lie.
@SaturnSnowman
Mario galaxy won tons of awards, bioshock just won 2 more ...if you check the second and third games whit most awards per year the list is balanced and doesnt look that much western biased
Bioshock - 47
Super Mario Galaxy - 45 (including Awards 2008)
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare - 22 (including Awards 2008)
Portal - 13
Rock Band - 6
Halo 3 - 6 (including Awards 2008)
Crysis - 4
Mass Effect - 4
The Orange Box - 4
The Witcher - 2
Assassin's Creed - 1
Company of Heroes - 1
Crackdown - 1
Guitar Hero III - 1
Ratchet & Clank - 1I am your fatherIts a decent list - I own 6 of the games on the list. But, Bioshock is probably my favorite game from that list, although I found enjoyment out of all 6 of the games."Sex: sure, it can be fun alone, but it's more fun in a group, when people bring drugs." - KDTProjektThere's only one game on that list I still play. KOTORSticking feathers up your butt does not make you a chicken!I think that all of those games are good games and deserving of the award (except twd)
Although the lack of Nintendo games (and only one game from Japan), particularly Mario Galaxy, makes me question the legitamacy of the list.TC is going to ruffle some feathers now...You know how much people gets tired of Naughty Dog winning.
Like me bragging about the Patriots.Warning: I have a different views about stuff so try not to get worked up. OK?Joshjosh022 posted...I think that all of those games are good games and deserving of the award (except twd)
Although the lack of Nintendo games (and only one game from Japan), particularly Mario Galaxy, makes me question the legitamacy of the list.
Yeah you have to consider the sources.I don't drink. I don't smoke. I don't do drugs. I am your sXe hero.
They should build a mosque in mecca. Right next to the dome of the rock. -- Lord Sideousiiiiiiiiiiiii posted...random_man9119 posted...
Huh... So I haven't cared for a "dominant" GOTY since 2008 except for Skyrim... Not entirely surprised...
you seriously skipped red dead redemption? that might have been one of the greatest games ever, kinda.
I watched my uncle play a bunch of it... And it just wasn't something that interested me...NNID:MrOddities|PSN:OddGamer2013
Playing:Persona 5|Smite|The Binding of Isaac Afterbirth+|Warframe|Ever Oasis|Splatoon 2|Diablo 3|RPG Maker FES|FortniteGamingGod posted...Incase you were wondering what game took the most awards for each given year since 2003, well here they are.
2003 STAR WARS KOTR
2004 HALF LIFE 2
2005 RESIDENT EVIL 4
2006 ELDER SCROLLS OBLIVION
2007 BIOSHOCK
2008 FALLOUT 3
2009 UNCHARTED 2
2010 RED DEAD REDEMPTION
2011 ELDER SCROLLS SKYRIM
2012 WALKING DEAD
2013 THE LAST OF US
2014 DRAGON AGE INQUISITION
2015 WITCHER 3
2016 UNCHARTED 4
BIGGEST WINNER : Naughty dog studios
https://gotypicks.blogspot.com/?m=1
So there we have it.
What do you have to say?
Do you think it was well deserved?
What 2017 game should join this list as the biggest winner?
I remember a lot of Halo, Halo 2, Halo 3's. Where did they go?
Naughty Dog is meh. This list is filled with overrated and over-hyped games. Meh list."You like death? Then die!" - EDF: 2017Joshjosh022 posted...I think that all of those games are good games and deserving of the award (except twd)
Although the lack of Nintendo games (and only one game from Japan), particularly Mario Galaxy, makes me question the legitamacy of the list.
Seems pretty legitimate to me.My father has an NFL Ravens championship ring...
true story.X-Fallout-X posted...GamingGod posted...
Incase you were wondering what game took the most awards for each given year since 2003, well here they are.
2003 STAR WARS KOTR
2004 HALF LIFE 2
2005 RESIDENT EVIL 4
2006 ELDER SCROLLS OBLIVION
2007 BIOSHOCK
2008 FALLOUT 3
2009 UNCHARTED 2
2010 RED DEAD REDEMPTION
2011 ELDER SCROLLS SKYRIM
2012 WALKING DEAD
2013 THE LAST OF US
2014 DRAGON AGE INQUISITION
2015 WITCHER 3
2016 UNCHARTED 4
BIGGEST WINNER : Naughty dog studios
https://gotypicks.blogspot.com/?m=1
So there we have it.
What do you have to say?
Do you think it was well deserved?
What 2017 game should join this list as the biggest winner?
I remember a lot of Halo, Halo 2, Halo 3's. Where did they go?
Naughty Dog is meh. This list is filled with overrated and over-hyped games. Meh list.
Or u just have garbage tasteYou want facts? I bring themI only really agree with 2 of those.I...am...Alexander. Tremble...before me... Worship...my greatness... I shall ascend to the heavens...SaturnSnowman posted...Mr_Big_Boss posted...
SaturnSnowman posted...
No Nintendo games? Seems biased.
2002 was the last time they had a real contender for GOTY. They have 2017 locked though.
Pretty sure Twilight Princess and Mario Galaxy were both incredibly well-liked by just about every review website the years they came out. To say they aren't even contenders is a lie.
Indeed they were contenders. They even won in alot of sites but not just the majorityYou want facts? I bring themEl_Zaggy posted...Super Mario Galaxy received Game of the Year 2007 awards from various big and influential game media such as IGN, gamespot, kotaku, gametrailers, edge, famitsu, gamerankings,
even gamefaqs readers chosen it as 2007's goty.
TC just fanboyed out the list to exclude it.
Dude are you fucking serious? Even I thought it was Mario Galaxy till I saw an actual site that keep tabs on things like this and proved beyond all reasonable doubt that it was Bioshock
The most popular sites gave it to Mario Galaxy but the majority when counting less popular sites gave it to Bioshock
And here we are counting all relevant sites hence why Bioshock took itYou want facts? I bring themthere should be a game of the decade award every 10 years that takes all the goty winners and compares them to see which is the best.Gamertag XL: CRAZYjump, PSN: CRAZIERjump
Winner: Dark Souls.....2, Honorable Mentions: Fallout 3, Gears of War, Left 4 Dead, Dead Space, BioshockGamingGod posted...El_Zaggy posted...
Super Mario Galaxy received Game of the Year 2007 awards from various big and influential game media such as IGN, gamespot, kotaku, gametrailers, edge, famitsu, gamerankings,
even gamefaqs readers chosen it as 2007's goty.
TC just fanboyed out the list to exclude it.
Dude are you fucking serious? Even I thought it was Mario Galaxy till I saw an actual site that keep tabs on things like this and proved beyond all reasonable doubt that it was Bioshock
The most popular sites gave it to Mario Galaxy but the majority when counting less popular sites gave it to Bioshock
And here we are counting all relevant sites hence why Bioshock took it
There are just too many sites shelling out awards.
We need something official, à la Oscars/Academy Awards.These are the numbers of fucks I gave for GotY winners from 2003 to 2016:
2003 ZERO
2004 ZERO
2005 ZERO
2006 ZERO
2007 ZERO
2008 ZERO
2009 ZERO
2010 ZERO
2011 ZERO
2012 ZERO (Though it was a pretty shitty year if Walking Dead won)
2013 ZERO
2014 ZERO
2015 ZERO
2016 ZERO
And here's a prediction for the future, as for the number of fucks I'll also give to 2017 GotY winner:
2017 ZEROInsert funny / cool / original / meaningful quote here.@SaturnSnowman posted...Mr_Big_Boss posted...
SaturnSnowman posted...
No Nintendo games? Seems biased.
2002 was the last time they had a real contender for GOTY. They have 2017 locked though.
Pretty sure Twilight Princess and Mario Galaxy were both incredibly well-liked by just about every review website the years they came out. To say they aren't even contenders is a lie.
pretty clear from the list in the OP that quality is not a determining factor in this discussion...
I mean, look at all the quality Wii U games in 2014 (its only good year) yet DA:I won GOTY.... thats a joke lol. Then we see Walking Dead in there, what the fuck is this?
Then add the fact that we are supposed to be counting up individual awards in here just to show that ND is so great.... its sad tbh"Besides the multiplatforms and exclusives, what else was there on PS4?" - Karmic Dragon2003Comyx posted...GamingGod posted...
El_Zaggy posted...
Super Mario Galaxy received Game of the Year 2007 awards from various big and influential game media such as IGN, gamespot, kotaku, gametrailers, edge, famitsu, gamerankings,
even gamefaqs readers chosen it as 2007's goty.
TC just fanboyed out the list to exclude it.
Dude are you fucking serious? Even I thought it was Mario Galaxy till I saw an actual site that keep tabs on things like this and proved beyond all reasonable doubt that it was Bioshock
The most popular sites gave it to Mario Galaxy but the majority when counting less popular sites gave it to Bioshock
And here we are counting all relevant sites hence why Bioshock took it
There are just too many sites shelling out awards.
We need something official, à la Oscars/Academy Awards.
AgreedYou want facts? I bring themwell geoff keighley's game awards wants to be the oscars of video games but still fail at it.
the problem with goty awards is that some of these so called 'gaming medias' are clearly biased. Some of them are 1 platform only. Like PC gamer for example.(edited 1 hour ago)quoteOnly games I've completed off that list are the Uncharted games.First comes smiles, then lies. Last is gunfire.GamingGod posted...Ultimaspirit posted...
Am I missing something? Three Bethesda games, three ND games.
When calculating all awards
Tlou is actually the 2nd most awarded game ever
So people with no taste AND no understanding of originality got it.Here comes a New Web Comic for gamers, BY a gamer, Critique is welcomed as long as you are positive about it.
http://hatetheplayer.thewebcomic.com/Comyx posted...GamingGod posted...
El_Zaggy posted...
Super Mario Galaxy received Game of the Year 2007 awards from various big and influential game media such as IGN, gamespot, kotaku, gametrailers, edge, famitsu, gamerankings,
even gamefaqs readers chosen it as 2007's goty.
TC just fanboyed out the list to exclude it.
Dude are you fucking serious? Even I thought it was Mario Galaxy till I saw an actual site that keep tabs on things like this and proved beyond all reasonable doubt that it was Bioshock
The most popular sites gave it to Mario Galaxy but the majority when counting less popular sites gave it to Bioshock
And here we are counting all relevant sites hence why Bioshock took it
There are just too many sites shelling out awards.
We need something official, à la Oscars/Academy Awards.
there are tons of movie awards tooo...as many as game awardsflkid posted...And Bloodborne is still a better game than all of those listed.
You mean the same bloodborne that was destroyed by Witcher 3 back in 2015? Oh pleaseYou want facts? I bring themZignoff posted...GamingGod posted...
Ultimaspirit posted...
Am I missing something? Three Bethesda games, three ND games.
When calculating all awards
Tlou is actually the 2nd most awarded game ever
So people with no taste AND no understanding of originality got it.
Originality dsnt mean quality. Something already popular can still be done in a way it trumps everything else. Including the so called originalsYou want facts? I bring themCobra1010 posted...SaturnSnowman posted...
No Nintendo games? Seems biased.
If nintendos zelda were multiplat, im sure wind waker would be a dominant goty.
But sadly Nintendo are too greedy to share. Well its not like they can help it. They only have a few titles to move their consoles to stay afloat in this brutal competitive gaming market.
Surely you feel the same about all exclusives (that companies with exclusives are greedy)? Otherwise that'd be hypocritical. :)
And you know Nintendo has far and away the most exclusive IPs of the big three, right?
That being said, half the list is good and half is awful. RDR, both Uncharted games, etc. are good. DA:I though? Wretched.Play games, not companies.(edited 13 minutes ago)quote- Boards
- PlayStation 4
- These were the dominant goty winners from 2003 to 2016
No comments:
Post a Comment